Watery Reflections — Image Comments
Comment on "..."
(Click image to toggle full screen)
Score "..."
(Click image to toggle full screen)
This month's theme asks you to submit up to three images of reflections in water - a river, lake, ocean, puddle, glass of water - any watery reflection. It could be abstract, mirrored, or a distorted image.
Our rainy weather should help with ideas. Good luck,
The following members helped provide feedback on 55 images:
Brenda Fairfax, Nancy M, Milada Dzevitskaya, Tim S, Janet Pearson, Harry T, and Karen J
Most helpful member was Nancy M, who made 52 comments covering 52 images.
12 voting members helped rank the images.
Top Ranked Images
The Scent of Spring
by Debi N
Strengths:Suggestions:Well. Very nice finding. The main object in focus.
I might crop off the left flower.
I believe, the image will be much better.
Also would like to see this image in B&W. Probably will be pretty interesting
- Strengths:
Fun, seasonal interpretation of the theme. Nice capture of the surface ripples.
Tropical Colour
by Debi N
- Strengths:Suggestions:
Gorgeous reflections. Good interpretation of the theme. Great colors
Looks too busy. Maybe have to crop differently
- Strengths:
Fun interpretation of the theme; A bit of trompe d'oeil mixing the reflected foliage with the leaves floating on the surface, etc. Nice balance between the bright red on the left and the bit of openess / blue sky on the right. Interesting textures, etc.
Poor Visibility
by Harry T
- Strengths:Suggestions:
A beautiful misty scene which evokes the feeling of being at the water on a cloudy day. Strong detail in the foreground fading into the mist along a strong diagonal line.
Response:While the reflection is clearly there, it is more framing than subject. Pulling back to include more of the reflection, perhaps a portrait composition, might make the image more about the reflection. But, it is a truly lovely image, just as it is.
Thanks for your comment! I agree with you in that including more of the reflection would better reflect the theme.
Misty Mountains
by Harry T
- Strengths:Response:
What lovely symmetry! The curves, colours and alternating light and darker areas create a very appealing series of undulating bands. Very effective and really great for this theme.
Thans very much for taking the time to comment.
- Strengths:Response:
Rich and saturated creation which is very energetic and appealing. Interesting how the rocks under the water shine through the reflection. Nice long DOF with the image appearing sharp throughout, highlighting all the interesting textures.
Thank you!
Heavenly Gold
by Harry T
- Strengths:Response:
Such a clean, fresh, painterly image - gorgeous. Good balance and clarity between actual and reflected portions. The light is just right and the colour palette subtle in range contrast. Well done.
Thanks very much for the comment!
- Strengths:Suggestions:
Great finding. Excellent composition with the point on the gazebo. Your eye runs to it from the right side. Great clear reflection
Response:Well done. Very cheerful image
Thank you!
- Strengths:Response:
A very interesting palette, very appealing. A "rules of thirds" and very attractive composition which suits the subject and theme perfectly.
Thank you!
Reflective Temple
by Nathan E
- Strengths:Suggestions:
Interesting finding. Good composition
Probably the image underexpose ( maybe on my screen) and I am not sure if the bright spot fit the image
- Strengths:Suggestions:
Interesting subject for the theme;
As the sky is flat it adds little to the image. Consider cropping some from the top, which will also serve to focus more attention on the subject reflection.
Seeing double
by Kate L
- Strengths:Suggestions:
Colours are rich and appealing
Perhaps too much peripheral distraction...? Might prefer to see the central subjects taking up more of the frame (a tighter crop), as they are bold and provide the lion's share of the best reflections, which draws the eye.
- Strengths:Suggestions:
Good use of diagonals to create interesting shapes. Appealing colour palette. The water lilies define the surface of the water and draw attention to the reflection.
For the theme it would be good if the pool took up more of the real estate of the image. Consider a crop from the top and the left.
Boat Reflections on the Fraser
by Tim S
- Strengths:
It's a beautiful composition! I like the leading lines ie the boats and horizon line. The texture pattern is very eye pleasing also.
- Strengths:Suggestions:
I love the perspective / POV -- beautifully composed with excellent light qualities.
As satisfying as the image is overall, for this particular theme I don't get enough of a sense of the reflections being a major component.
- Strengths:Suggestions:
It is a piece of Art for me. Composition, colors, clarity, and post-processing is just great.
Well done
- Strengths:Suggestions:
Beautiful tones which suit the painterly treatment perfectly. A lovely, serene interpretation of the theme. Strong diagonal energy. Good use of void space which frames the subjects leaving the attention there.
The painting effect is very attractive, but the crackling draws the attention away from the subject. Perhaps is could be toned down just a touch.
Leaning Stumps Reflected
by Geoffrey G
- Strengths:
I like how the stumps are silhouetted, which emphasizes the fact that they are long since dead. The reflection pattern draws the eye into the scene and the hazy mountains give a feeling of depth to your excellent composition.
- Strengths:
A strong, dramatic interpretation of the theme. A well layered composition
Ringed Reflection
by Geoffrey G
- Strengths:
Terrific for the theme; though definitely watery, also a refreshing departure from the myriad bodies of water. Great geometry in the juxtaposition of the reflected shapes, and the B&W is a super choice here. Dramatic and visually arresting.
- Strengths:Suggestions:
Interesting mix of strong diagonal lines and the round shapes.
The main subject of the image - the bike racks - are in soft focus. The image would be strengthened with a bit more sharpness.
Stormy
by Deanna T
- Strengths:Suggestions:
Bright and coloursful; A strong interpretation of the them. The wet street is a great subject. Good angle and moment to get both the red and green lights reflected. The textures on the street make some diagonal lines that lend energy and interest.
Because, for the theme, the story is about the reflections, a small crop off the top to increase the percentage of the image that is reflection.
Rainy Evening Reflection
by Deanna T
- Strengths:Suggestions:
A very nice use of rainy streets; good exposure with strong contrast on the street to give that sense of "wet". Nice balance in the composition with the figure looking into the intersection, rewarded with the other figure across the street. Suggests a story.
Nit-picking. There is a bit of bright orange at the top edge, and a handle on the right edge that distract a bit from an otherwise really strong image. Consider if a crop would help wtihout damaging the composition, or clone.
Mother Reflection
by Barb T
- Strengths:Suggestions:
A charming subject; Interesting composition with the strong diagonal line leading the eye from the front reflection / subject to the supporting reflections behind. Triangles lend energy to the composition.
The main subject seems to be the ducks. The image would be enhanced if that part of the image was sharper.
Fraser Floaters
by Jim W
- Strengths:Suggestions:
A spare and graphic interpretation of the theme. Interesting use of the mist and water that seems to let the subject float. with new horizon, or dividing line between sky and water.
The strength of this image is the quiet drama and silhouette. Lifing the contrast, or the blacks to enhance the silhouette of the front subject would enhance the drama.
Pink
by Jim W
- Strengths:Suggestions:
A fun subject for the theme; the mist simplifies and isolates the subject.
The reflection is a very small part of the composition and is overwhelmed by the pink, making the image feel unbalanced. Consider a crop off the left to let the eye explore the rest of the image.
Rainbow Aquabus
by Ian P
- Strengths:
The reflections are so bright and colourful that they grab the eye and keep it in the frame! An artistic image that suits the theme perfectly!
- Strengths:
A cheerful and fun interpretation of the theme! The composition works well to focus attention on the reflection which suits the theme well.
- Strengths:Suggestions:
Wonde interpretation of the theme;. Great perspective and POV. Onlly the bottom portion of the boat is visible giving empahsis on the boat reflection which fills more than half the frame so the eye goes directly to the reflections. Good definition and contrast throughout. Colours of the reflections are vibrant and very clear.
The intense blue colour of the water is unnatural and IMO . Suggest oning down the saturation a bit. The wash from the boat is blown out white patch and is detracts from the boat reflections
Fishing in the Clouds
by Kathy H
- Strengths:
A bit of trompe d'oeil - holds attention very well. Actually a bit Escher-esque. The reflection and mirroring makes a strong composition with energetic diagonals and triangles. Good exposure; nice range of tones.
- Strengths:Suggestions:
Interesting composition. . Good balance of exposure, contrast, tones in the foreground and sky background.
Response:Not sure this qualifies for the theme . The inverted fisherman does not appear to be a reflection but a copy of the original fisherman that was inverted and pasted below the original fisherman.
Thank you for the feedback. It occured to me that flipping the image might make it harder to connect to the theme, but it looked so much more interesting and confusing to the eye that I went for it anyway!
Alone in the Fog
by Michael D
- Strengths:
Really like the smooth and calm water. The tree looks like a bonsai on the peaceful water.
- Strengths:
Such a beautiful subject and moment with the ducks really adding to the story; the centred composition really supports the calm and quiet of the subject. The monochrome treatment likewise simplifies and adds to the sense of quite. Definitely one of the stronger images in the theme.
A Stream of Trees.
by Michael D
- Strengths:
Beautifully done. Really like how you show the details of the trees on the water rather than above it.
- Strengths:
Dramatic and quiet at the same time! A lovely interpretation of the theme. Your composition lets the reflection be the key part of the story with the simple lines of the trees support and frame. The monochrome treatment simplified what could be a cluttered scene.
Sunset
by Milada D
- Strengths:
The light is divine, as is your excellent composition!! Strong lines and foreground framing make this an eye catching image!
- Strengths:
A quiet, serene moment; lovely colours; strong diagonal line leading the eye into the image; appropriate exposure; Nice use of the branches and grasses as framing.
False Creek Reflections
by Peter_J E
- Strengths:Suggestions:
A fun and graphic interpretation of the theme; The strong colours lend energy.
With the boat almost touching each side of the image, the subject feels a bit crowded. If the situaton allowed for it, a bit more space at either end would lend visual ease.
Lilies glow
by Milada D
- Strengths:Suggestions:
A lovely, serene subject, recorded very nicely. Pretty colours. The triad of open blossoms makes a nice composition.
This is a lovely imnage, but the reflection isn't a strong part of the story of the image. Consider cropping from the top to put the reflections in greater focus.
- Strengths:Suggestions:
Wonderful composition; love the soft, saturated colouration of the lilies. and their clear reflection in the water. Title is appropriate as the flowering lilies really stand out against the darkened and blurry background and surrounding lily pads. Well done
Nothing to suggest.
Sinking
by Janet P
- Strengths:Suggestions:
A very interesting interpretation of the theme; The monochrome translation leave the attention on the subject's interesting textures. The balance between the floating building (2/3) and the brighter sunken one (1/3) works very well.
The textures on the floating building is a key part of the subject. Some added clarity to ehance those texture might reward.
Bridge Over Water
by Janet P
- Strengths:Suggestions:
A lovely moment, timed very well. Intereseting sky over an intricate silhouette. Strong interpretation of the theme.
The silhouette is a key component of the image. That might be stronger with a touch more contrast, or plunging the black a bit to make the contrast very crisp.
Reflected Rings
by Peter_J E
- Strengths:
A strong interpretation of the theme. A very appealing graphic feel, with the repeating shapes. The diagonal composition appeals. Nice balance between the reflection and the rest of the image. The monochrome translation simplifies the image so the attention stays on the shapes aned composition. Bonus points for local subject.
Rippling Boughs
by Brenda F
- Strengths:Suggestions:
A unique and ianteresting interpretation of the theme. A bit of an ominous abstraction which intrigues.
The strength of the image is the drama. The abstraction might be a bit more dramatic if the white was lifted a bit, and / or a touch of contrast.
- Strengths:Suggestions:
This is a creative intriguing capture of tree "boughs" reflection in the water . The wavy, disorted shapes of the branches reflection give this image an abstract and artistic look. The black silhouette branches contrasts nicely against the light background
A number of branches are covered with smudge areas that diminishes the quality of an otherwise terrific image.
Autumn Pond
by Brenda F
- Strengths:
Really like the composition and colour tone, very calming and peaceful.
- Strengths:
Lovely subject for the theme. Bonus for a local subject. Nice balance with the large foliage at the left balancing the waterfall. The top-bottom symmetry supports and ehances the serenity of the subject.
Morning Calmness at the Resort
by Brenda F
- Strengths:Suggestions:
Very interesting reflection. Makes me want to go for a vacation.
Response:In my opinion, the colour saturation is a bit strong.
Believe it or not this came out of the camera as is. No saturation added.
- Strengths:Suggestions:
Fun interpretation of the theme. Nice diagonal lines. Good detail. The bit of deck anchors the image.
It would be interesting to see the image if there was something small floating on the surface of the water. But, even without, a lovely image.
Reflective Castle
by Rick L
- Strengths:
Beautiful scenary and reflection.
- Strengths:
Wonderful scene - perfect for the theme. Lovely light - that cloudy sky made a great softbox. The relatively symetrical composition suits the feel of the scene. The tiny little figures lend scale. Subtle lines leading the eye to the castle.
A River Runs Through It
by Bill Bentley
- Strengths:Suggestions:
That beautiful, mirror-like water is perfect for the theme. A beautiful moment. Perfected exposued. Nice use of framing of the reflection.
For the theme, and as a landscape, consider cropping some more of the sky out. The story is the reflection, and a panorama presentation would suit this landscape.
- Strengths:Suggestions:
Very nice image. Lovely composition with foreground and background and using the rule of third.
Excellent colors, clarity of reflection
No any suggestions
Across the River
by Karen J
- Strengths:Suggestions:
Lovely glowing reflection. A good capture of later afternoon light. Nice rich colours. Strongly vertical verticals. Bonus for New West content.
Except for a few window reflections the image appears a bit underexposed, and the shadows are deeply plunged. That fights with the calm feel the composition and moment suggest. Consider lifting the exposure and especially the shadows. Reduce contrast just a touch. It really doesn't matter of the sparks of reflection off the windows are blown.
Puddle Riding
by Barb T
- Strengths:Suggestions:
An interesting and appealing image with a story. The monochrome presentation simplifies the image so that we can enjoy the textures and details. The spashes on the legs along with the puddles imply a story.
For the them, it would be great if the shot could be reframed to include more of the reflection of the cycle and rider in the image. This would make the reflection component stronger. Outside of the theme, the composition is great.
Reflection Bridge
by Barb T
- Strengths:Suggestions:
Bonus for being a New West image. A fun moment; blue skies after the rains. Perfect reflection time. Nicely placed, strong subject in the puddle. Very appealing colours. Enough dry detail to frame the reflection. Nicely done.
If the bricks at the near edge of the image were in focus more, it would give the image a more focused look.
Waiting for the Big One
by Karen J
- Strengths:Suggestions:
A really charming subject. The reflection is a small part of the image, but important, so a nice interpretation of the theme. Nice detail. Love the splashing around the dog's feet.
I would have liked to see some detail of the dog's face and fur. Difficult to shoot a dark dog against a bright background. It looks like there was room to over-expose a touch. If not, the file might have enough information to lift the blacks selectively to get a bit of detail.
The Blue Hour
by Bill Bentley
- Strengths:
Stunning image! Perfect placement of the horizon for this reflection, excellent focus, lighting, and composition. Breathtaking! I honestly don't know how someone will beat this one!
- Strengths:Suggestions:
A glarmorous and well crafted images of a blue hour sky line. Wonderful rich blues; nice long exposure to smooth out the water. The top-bottom centred composition is serene and suits the moment. Good balance between the brighter right side and the larger left. An elegant interpretation of the theme.
Nothing to offer. Sorry.
- Strengths:Suggestions:
It is my favorite image with excellent clarity and colors.
Great work at blue hours
Very well done, no any suggestions
- Strengths:Suggestions:
Very good image of the skyline of Vancouver and very colourful and clear reflections of the buildings and Science World taken at the magical hour so the details of the buildings are shown. Nicely done.
Nothing to suggest
Copyright © 2005-2024 New Westminster Photography Club. All Rights Reserved. | Icons by Freepik & Google from www.flaticon.com
The toning and treatment give an interesting antique postcard look of a modern subject. Interesting and appealing. The panoramic aspect ratio works well for the subject.